Hairy Munky wrote:
#3 is the best by far and I think this is a prime example of why (qualified) SOTW Judges need to return.
It really depends what you think the people who make the sigs want to hear. Using judges, the sigs might be better appreciated and given a "qualified" review, but the judges don't represent the people entirely. They simply are the "best of the best" (hopefully) when it comes to judging sigs. On the other hand, letting the users vote gives a baser opinion and broader consensus, but with varying degrees of opinion and appreciation. There are pros and cons to both. Either way, it the general appreciation for the sigs that counts.
Or at least that's the way I see it.
Ppr Kkut wrote:
Even though I entered, I like number 3, for 2 reasons.
1: I love the blends of colors.
2: Who doesn't love that channel? I mean, the sign is a pecok, or however you spell it. ^.^