Halo 3 or Call of Duty 4

CreepyPirate · **Posted:** April 28th, 2008, 10:19 am

I usually prefer sci-fi over realism too. If it wasn't for the perks and killing streak rewards I'd not look twice at COD4 multiplayer.

In fact COD4 is the only FPS war game I've liked, the rest are all over the top, not really creating the true feeling that you're in a war and oddly seem to be obsessed with Americans. COD4 mixed it up just a bit, russians, americans, brits had an interesting plot and good characters.

Pity COD5 will blow, going back to WW2. :roll:

Adbot · **Posted:** April 28th, 2008, 10:19 am

Dragon · **Posted:** April 28th, 2008, 11:45 am

CreepyPirate wrote:

I usually prefer sci-fi over realism too. If it wasn't for the perks and killing streak rewards I'd not look twice at COD4 multiplayer.

In fact COD4 is the only FPS war game I've liked, the rest are all over the top, not really creating the true feeling that you're in a war and oddly seem to be obsessed with Americans. COD4 mixed it up just a bit, russians, americans, brits had an interesting plot and good characters.

Pity COD5 will blow, going back to WW2. :roll:

What did you honestly expect from Treyarch. :roll:

Just look forward to CoD6.

Slimppu · **Posted:** April 28th, 2008, 12:24 pm

ix pk rng ix wrote:

So you like scifi over real life awesome graphic.. wow first person i ever seen like that lol no offense

Halo 3's and CoD4's craphics are both just as good. :/

Al3X · **Posted:** May 5th, 2008, 1:50 pm

CoD4 is much better in my opinion. I was recently on a MLG Halo 3 team, (I really dont care if anyone believes me or not, it's true) and then we had some issues, disbanded and I began playing CoD4 again which has proven much more fun.

ix pk rng ix · **Posted:** May 5th, 2008, 6:43 pm

Slimppu wrote:

ix pk rng ix wrote:

So you like scifi over real life awesome graphic.. wow first person i ever seen like that lol no offense

Halo 3's and CoD4's craphics are both just as good. :/

Not even close

CreepyPirate · **Posted:** May 5th, 2008, 7:21 pm

ix pk rng ix wrote:

Slimppu wrote:

ix pk rng ix wrote:

So you like scifi over real life awesome graphic.. wow first person i ever seen like that lol no offense

Halo 3's and CoD4's craphics are both just as good. :/

Not even close

Oh but they are.

It's just a different art style, Halo uses lots of colours and has a totally different approach it's very bright. COD4 is very dark, gloomy shades mostly made up of grays, it makes it look a hell of a lot better and realistic than it is.

Only way to really figure who's graphics are better you'd have to get into some really nit-picky technical garbage that you don't tend to notice while playing, much like the textures, in cod4 there very low detail, next time you start up a multiplayer game just take a look at the floor, blocky yucky textures, if you did that in halo you'd see some very high detailed textures, not any of that blocky garbage, that isn't even noticeable when playing it's only when you stop and examine it.

All comes down to art style really.

Adbot · **Posted:** May 5th, 2008, 7:21 pm

Total Plox · **Posted:** May 5th, 2008, 8:23 pm

CreepyPirate wrote:

ix pk rng ix wrote:

Slimppu wrote:

Halo 3's and CoD4's craphics are both just as good. :/

Not even close

Oh but they are.

It's just a different art style, Halo uses lots of colours and has a totally different approach it's very bright. COD4 is very dark, gloomy shades mostly made up of grays, it makes it look a hell of a lot better and realistic than it is.

Only way to really figure who's graphics are better you'd have to get into some really nit-picky technical garbage that you don't tend to notice while playing, much like the textures, in cod4 there very low detail, next time you start up a multiplayer game just take a look at the floor, blocky yucky textures, if you did that in halo you'd see some very high detailed textures, not any of that blocky garbage, that isn't even noticeable when playing it's only when you stop and examine it.

All comes down to art style really.

+1

You can't compare two completely different styles of art and determine which one is better.

I tend to view Halo 3 as more of a party game - a game to play with multiple friends just to have a good time, while I think CoD4 is more of a strategy game, which takes real skill and requires more attention. All in all, CoD4 is better to me, but they're both great games.

ryan1 · **Posted:** May 5th, 2008, 9:05 pm

Call of Duty 4. No contest. Much better gameplay. It requires strategy. Halo 3 is just a simple FPS that a 5 year old can be good at.

whitedragon · **Posted:** May 6th, 2008, 2:48 pm

Although I'm a huge halo fan I have to go with CoD4 because I like the realistic feel to the game and I get kicks out of knifing someone and running off before they see me.

Marco · **Posted:** May 20th, 2008, 2:35 pm

Do you think another COD will come out?

Ryan · **Posted:** May 20th, 2008, 2:43 pm

Marco995 wrote:

Do you think another COD will come out?

Yes CoD5 is set for November. Unfortunately Treyarch are making it again so it's back to WW2

rikusora321 · **Posted:** May 20th, 2008, 4:50 pm

halo 3 easy.

ix pk rng ix · **Posted:** May 22nd, 2008, 3:33 pm

rikusora321 wrote:

halo 3 easy.

like first person..