2 FAKES

The first one has a few problems. Like a u on the persons clothes, a red dot floating in no where, and a white dot. Now for the fakes.

Top fake:

Luck is kind of messed up, like you said. And it's in all capitals, but everything else isn't. The clothing could use more details than just a few red lines. But the picture of your character and the clothing match up.

Bottom fake:

The crosses could use some more details. The teeth don't look very Runescapeish. Also, there are a few pixels at the bottom right of the equip screen. The "Rarity" is perfect, though.

On both:

I like how the weight changes from when you have a sword and when you don't. Most people would overlook that. It's not overdone (a good thing), but both have a few floating objects in them that shouldn't be there.

Overall:

3.5/5

First pic:
- the red is too consistent... you need to follow the shading.
- the sword looks like excalibur colored in. with a crayon.
- as mentioned before, there is a random red dot and a floating 'u.'
- the LUck looks handwritten.

Second pic:
- the crosses have no shading.
- there should be no black outline around the teeth... usually nothign on the character is outlined in black.
- there are random lines again near the bottom right.
- the Rarity is meh. there is a random line after the second 'r.' The 't' is a few pixels too low. The 'y' has the hook chopped off.