hey all, i'd like to argue a point.
lots of people seem to like the saradomin sword. it strong, fast, trains strength, has a good special attack... generally a good weapon. right? well i'd like to say its all a load of ****. there is nothing good about the saradomin sword. fact. and now i'll prove it.
things people usually say to defend the saradomin sword:
the saradomin sword is better than a whip: false
here's a stat comparison for the whip and saradomin sword:click
basically they are the same weapon, but here's the kicker. the saradomin sword is 2 handed, so youget no shield. if you like offense, you can use a rune defender and be 19 points more accurate, and 5 more strength with a whip, instead of the shield-less saradomin sword.
the saradomin sword has a good special attack: true
yes, its special attack is good, but one thing you're missing is that the dragon dagger, longsword, and mace all have good specials too, and 4 of them, not just one. at 99 strenght in the best gear you can imagine, you can literally 1hko any player with a lucky hit from the dds. scary? yes. true? yes. th edragon mace can hit upwards of 60, and the d long upwards of 55, more accurately than mace i might add, but this isnt' mace bashing, this is sara sword bashing. it is true that in the best gear, you can hit 45+ with a sara sword, but seing as i don't know the max hit of the special attack, i cannot tell you what the overall max is. (if you hit with the spec you get 2 hits)
edit: the special adds a magic attack dealing 5-15 damage in adition to your normal attack. this does not increase as your magic or any other level increases. it also has a chance of splashing, and dealing no damage. however, i've observed that what you hit with the magic attack refletcts the damage of the melee attack that turn. usually if you splash you'll hit 0 with the melee part, and if you get a 15 you hit closer to your max hit. so indeed its special attack is decent. but seing as you'll most likley be in melee gear with a negative magic attack bonus, it doesn't serve well for the saradomin sword's special attack.
sara sword's good special attack: dismissed
the saradomin sword has agressive strength training, you can't do that on a whip!
this also is true, but theres one thing they're missing. in a tournament or pking, training strenght doesn't matter.what matters is hitting hard and fast, thus a whip is better than a saradomin sword could ever be. if you insist on training strength with a good weapon, why not use a dragon longsword or scimitar with a rune defender?
69 slash 71 strength on dragon longsword, add the defender its 88 slash 76 strength. slightly weaker, more accurate, but slightly slower, yet with, as said earlier, one of the best special attacks of all dragon weapons.
67 slash 66 strength on dragon scimitar, add the defender its 86 slash and 71 strength, you'll hit at most 3 less damage then you would with a saradomin sword, hit at the same speed, and be slightly more accurate.
tell me, what do you think? is it worth paying 12m for a weapon constantly going down in price that is proved obsolete by gear thats requires 10 less attack anyway? talk about an lol.
so you're still unconvinced? you like your sara sword so much? i've got a better weapon for you. guaranteed. barrelchest anchor. 92 crush, yes crush, not slash, and 100 strength. attack speed is the same as a dragon longsword, barrows weapons, and the godsword. its special is 50% drain and doubles your chances of hitting. crush is the weakest defense of all melee armours. thus you have a great chance of hitting in the first place for a far more powerful weapon. it also can lower defense with its special, not by much, but if you hit well, its enough. oh and guess what... IT TRAINS STRENGTH. and its only 230k to get it, and its price will never go down because its not tradeable.
there you have it. evidence of the saradomin sword's failure, successfull alternatives. now discuss. thanks
|
